Colombia 10 day travel itinerary advice

I am traveling to Colombia for approximately 10 days in September. I am deciding between two itineraries, any advice is appreciated!

Option 1:

Day 1: Arrive in Medellin

Day 2: Medellin

Day 3: Medellin

Day 4: Medellin

Day 5: Medellin -> Guatape

Day 6: Guatape -> Jardin

Day 7: Jardin

Day 8: Jardin ->Medellin

Day 9: Medellin

Day 10: Flight home

Option 2:

Day 1: Arrive in Medellin

Day 2: Medellin

Day 3: Medellin

Day 4: Medellin

Day 5 Guatape day trip

Day 6: Flight to Cartagena

Day 7: Cartagena -> Isla Baru

Day 8: Isla Baru

Day 9: Isla Baru -> Cartagena fly to Medellin

Day 10: Fly home