The best pizza in Corvallis.
The best pizza in Corvallis is Cirello's, closely followed by Market of Choice and American Dream Pizza in a near-tie for second, as chosen by posters and commenters in this sub.
The full ranked list:
- Cirello's (35)
- Market of Choice (30)
- American Dream (29)
- Dirt Road (21)
- Woodstocks (18)
- Gathering Together Farm (16)
- Nomadic Pizza (8)
- Pie 5 (6)
- Papa's Pizza (5)
- Sky High (3)
- McMenamins and Kingfish Lounge (both with 2)
Honorable mentions: Ankeny Vineyard, Benny's Pizza Joint (Monroe), Ciddici's (Albany), Coburg Pizza Co. (Coburg), Conversion Brewing (Lebanon), Costco (Albany), Retro Pizza (Amity), Bread Board (Falls City), James Gang Pizza (Lebanon), PizzAmoré (Albany), Schmizza Public House (Lebanon), Southpaws (Albany), Spoleto’s Pizzaria & Wine Shop (Sweet Home), Yeasty Beasty (Monmouth)
RIP: 2 Stones, Cibelli's, DeMaggio's, Fireworks, New York Pizza, Pizza Pipeline, Round Table, Zerpoli
Methodology: I did a search of "best pizza" in this sub and found about a dozen posts about the subject. I tallied up positive references for pizza restaurants. I did not tally any negative references or arguments to the contrary. If there were agreeing follow up comments I did tally those. I decided to only count restaurants in the immediate Corvallis and Philomath area. Spots mentioned outside of that but not as far as Eugene or Salem are listed unranked (alphabetically) as honorable mentions. Closed locations are in the RIP list.
References:
- What's the best pizza place in Corvallis? (Gathering Together, Market of Choice (x6), Woodstocks, Cirello's (x2), Dirt Road (x5), Vinewood Taphouse, Nomadic Pizza, American Dream (x3), McMenamins (x2), Papa's Pizza)
- The best pizza in Corvallis, sadly, is at Market of Choice. (Market of Choice (x12), Dirt Road (x4), Gathering Together (x3), Cirello's, Vinewood Taphouse, Nomadic Pizza (x3), American Dream (x4), Woodstocks, Pie Five (x2)
- Whats the best pizza in town? (Market of Choice, American Dream (x2), Dirt Road, Gathering Together, Cirello's, Woodstocks)
- good pizza in corvallis? (Cirello's (x13), American Dream (x8), Gathering Together (x3), Woodstocks (x6), Market of Choice (x7), Dirt Road (x5), Papa's (x2), Kingfish Lounge (x2), Sky High, Pie Five
- Hidden food gems in the boonies? (Gathering Together)
- Best pizza in Corvallis? (Cirello's (x2), Woodstocks (x2), Gathering Together, American Dream (x4), Papa's
- Neapolitan pizza in town? (Gathering Together (x3), Nomadic Pizza (x2), Cirello's (x2), American Dream (x2), Woodstocks, Pie Five
- Love pizza (American Dream, Woodstocks)
- Pizza rundown (Dirt Road, Gathering Together, Papa's, Pie Five, Sky High)
- Woodstocks vs Cirello's? (Cirello's (x9), Woodstocks, Market of Choice, Dirt Road (x3), Nomadic Pizza
- Market of Choice pizza (Woodstocks, Dirt Road (x2), Gathering Together, Cirello's (x4), Market of Choice (x3), Nomadic Pizza, Sky High, Pie Five, American Dream)
- Pizzas (American Dream (x4), Woodstocks (x3), Cirello's, Gathering Together
Conclusions: Draw your own!
Future versions: I may come back in a year to collate subsequent postings. I won't revisit the ones I already posted. I'm not going to use any votes in this thread to update the totals.