Louis tongue/Violet eyes

Okay, maybe I'm biased because I LOVE Louis, and he's definitely in my top 5 characters.. BUT!... I think that when you save Violet and he gets his tongue cut out, it is worse than when you save Louis, and Violet is blinded in one eye. Especially with how she reacts on the ship PRIOR to the explosion.

Does anyone else agree or am I on my own here?