Just booked! Need hotel recs plz!

So I went back and forth about which island to visit and based on our airfares and a cursory view of hotels on the island we chose the Grand Cayman!

We’d like to stay somewhere small or medium sized with a pool and ocean views. A boutique feel is our fav! We aren’t big adventurists but we do like to see the city or nightlife, depending on the hotel vibe. We don’t want to have to rent a car unless it’s just absolutely necessary.

Our budget is about $2500 for the entire stay - 4 nights mid June. 😬

Any ideas?